Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Public perception of unions during the 1980s

A basic academic rule is that old studies – especially those that are twenty years old – have extremely limited usefulness. But if they can't solve a problem, such studies sometimes still help inform debate.

As this blog has reported and commented on, there is quite a bit of hostility emerging as the current transit strike drags on. While violence and malice obviously shouldn't be encouraged, a 1988 study shows that the appearance of media to "go negative" against unions or at least favour management is nothing new.

Geoff Walsh analyzed the perception of trade unions in both media and by the general public at large in a 1988 issues of the International Labour Review. The following are excerpts from the article (found here, subscription necessary) that provide this debate some historical perspective:
The role played by the media, especially television, in setting the public’s “agenda” – defining political, social and economic issues by order of importance – may help to swing public opinion behind government or employer action against trade unions. In any event, there can be few unions today that do not recognise the crucial part played by the media in shaping their public image – and few that are not concerned about the dismal light in which they are generally shown.
Walsh referenced a number of telling polls from the 80s and decades prior:
  • In 1984, a Gallup poll "found that only 21 per cent of those surveyed had 'a great deal' or 'quite a lot' of confidence in, and respect for, trade unions." They ranked behind politicians and corporations who were also included in the survey.
  • Back in 1976, a Canadian Institute of Public Opinion survey found that 67 per cent of respondents felt there were "too many troublemakers and agitators among union leaders" – 17 per cent higher than 1966 and 27 per cent higher than 1956
Walsh offered his thoughts about the polling:
What these polls may indicate is an acceptance of basic trade union rights as a feature of democracy, but a rejection of what the public considers to be their “irresponsible” exercise.
Interestingly, Walsh points to unions who recognize their PR challenges. They include the Ontario Public Service Employees Union, which wrote in a 1985 report that "To put it mildly, this is what the professionals call "an image problem".

The Walsh study also shed light on the increasing wariness with which organized labour viewed mass media in the 80s. The U.S.-based AFL-CIO, for one, encouraged its members to differentiate betwwen "the bias with which the owners and managers of newspapers, radio and television stations often view unions [and] the ignorance from which many reporters and their bosses suffer."

This is likely not news to many readers. But it serves as a reminder that unions and management have long battled for the public-relations advantage (long before the 80s, of course), and unions have historically found themselves at a distinct disadvantage in that fight.

1 comment:

thanh nguyen said...

tựa hồ như muốn tràn lên bắt lấy Đoạn Vân ăn tươi nuốt sống. Nếu không
phải Mai Lan Ny kịp thời quát lên, phỏng chừng chúng đã sớm tràn lên
thật. Còn đám thủ hạ của Đoạn Vân xem ra cũng muốn tưng bừng đánh nhau
một trận.

- Đoạn Vân, chỉ cần ngươi ...

Mai Lan Ny còn muốn nói cái gì đó, nhưng mụ còn chưa nói xong, Đoạn Vân
lúc này xua tay như không muốn nghe nữa.

Đoạn Vân nói:

- Nếu các ngươi không sử dụng loại thủ đoạn hèn hạ đánh lén Thần Long
đảo của ta, không giết chết năm mươi Thần Long, cũng không cướp đi Ny
Khả công chúa của chúng ta, không tra tấn bức cung Ny Khả công chúa,
Đoạn Vân ta còn tính đến việc có muốn cứu trị cho nhi tử ngươi và một
đám cao thủ hải tộc nửa chết nửa sống hay không. Nhưng các ngươi đã làm
nên những sự tình này rồi, đừng trách ta, các ngươi trở về đi. Nhưng ...
dịch vụ dọn dẹp sổ sách trọn gói
kế toán cho giám đốc
học kế toán thực hành
tiếng anh cho người đi làm
khoá học kế toán excel
forum rao vat
mu private

trung tâm kế toán tại tphcm
dịch vụ kế toán trọn gói


diamond bay resort
chung cư hoà bình green city
five star garden

- Nhưng cái gì?

Câu này của Đoạn Vân làm cho Mai Lan Ny nhất thời nhúm lên một tia hy vọng.

Đoạn Vân cười nói: