Friday, December 17, 2010

Bus ride reading: Urban Nation

While browsing through the Ottawa Public Library collection, my interest was piqued by Alan Broadbent's Urban Nation: Why We Need to Give Power Back to the Cities to Make Canada Strong. Broadbent's premise is that Canada is becoming an increasingly urbanized nation, and the powers currently reserved for provinces need to be given to certain cities so that they've got the capacity and flexibility to respond to unique obstacles.

Although Broadbent mentions Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver as the cities which in particular deserve (and, in his opinion, need) this authority, his focus is undoubtedly on Toronto. Only a few passing examples show a concern for Vancouver, and Montreal is only mentioned a handful of times. The book is very much focussed on how a possible re-organization of government would benefit Toronto.

I was somewhat disappointed in Broadbent's dismissal of the City of Ottawa; although not nearly as large as the cities he focuses on, the Ottawa census metropolitan area is in the unique position of being affected by five levels of government as well as numerous different government agencies (the National Capital Commission and Parks Canada, to name a couple). If the idea is to build a more efficient and specifically capable municipal body, few Canadian cities would benefit from the change more than Ottawa would. But that wasn't a focus Broadbent dealt with, although I think the book would have benefited from it.

Much of the book is focussed on taxes: How taxes could shift towards urban uses, different taxation mechanisms that would open up to cities with province-like authorities, tax credits, and financing infrastructure projects through taxes. Which is rather interesting, if somewhat dry at times to read. Still, Broadbent brings up some very good points about the benefits that could come about.

Peculiarly, however, are the significant jurisdictional modifications Broadbent suggests towards the end of the book. Noting a disparity between representatives in the federal government and population between rural and urban populations, he not only proposes more representatives for urban areas, but also proposes a provincial reorganization for less populous provinces. The Atlantic provinces of Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, and New Brunswick would be united as "The Maritimes" (a label which I'm sure residents of Newfoundland and Labrador wouldn't appreciate, given that that province isn't a maritime province), while Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba would be united as "The Prairies". It seemed to come out of nowhere, but I suppose the point is that if cities are to gain powers, it's likely that someone else would have to give them up. In Broadbent's vision, that would be the lower-populated provinces across Canada.

Putting aside his vision for a "New Canada", Broadbent's point about a lack of sufficient powers setting cities back is very apropos. He uses more examples that I can recount here, but his bottom line is that Canadians are flocking to cities, and our governance structure--established almost 150 years ago--has failed to adjust to reflect changing realities. As it is, cities are subject to the whims of provincial and federal funding partners, virtually relegated to beggars coming hat-in-hand to other levels of government to seek funding for significant projects.

For readers interested in urban issues in Canada or the relationship between different levels of government would likely enjoy reading Urban Nation. But don't go into it expecting much of an Ottawa perspective.


WJM said...

Newfoundland and Labrador (like Quebec and BC) is a maritime province... Just not a Maritime one.

Fangyaya said...

cheap ray ban sunglasses
tory burch flats
abercrombie & fitch outlet
louis vuitton bags
celine outlet
michael kors outlet
ugg boots
mbt shoes
cheap beats headphones
coach outlet store online
louis vuitton
retro jordan shoes
lebron 13 shoes
kate spade outlet
jordan 3 powder blue
michael kors outlet online
ugg slippers
adidas factory outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors handbags
rolex watches
louis vuitton purses
coach outlet clearance
timberland shoes
polo ralph lauren
canada goose jackets
louis vuitton outlet
ugg boots
ugg boot uk
ladies cartier watches
nike roshe one
gucci outlet online
ralph lauren polo
coach outlet store
cheap true religion
louis vuitton outlet
uggs on sale
michael kors outlet online
christian louboutin outlet

eric yao said...

Coach Outlet

Christian Louboutin Shoes

Valentino Shoes

Michael Kors Outlet

Coach Factory Outlet

Coach Outlet Online

Coach Purses

Kate Spade Outlet

Toms Shoes

Hermes Belts

Louis Vuitton

Fendi Handbags

Giuseppe Shoes

Michael Kors Outlet

Stephen Curry Shoes

Salomon Shoes

North Face Outlet

Coach Outlet

North Face Outlet

Burberry Outlet

North Face Outlet

North Face Jackets

Skechers Shoes

Toms Outlet

North Face Outlet

Nike Air Max

Nike Hoodies

Marc Jacobs Handbags

Marc Jacobs Outlet

Jimmy Choo Shoes

Jimmy Choos

Burberry Belt

Louis Vuitton Belt

Salvatore Ferragamo

Marc Jacobs Handbags

Lululemon Outlet

True Religion Outlet

Tommy Hilfiger

Michael Kors Outlet

Coach Outlet

Red Bottoms

Kevin Durant Shoes

New Balance Outlet

Adidas Outlet

Coach Outlet Online

Stephen Curry Jersey

Vans Outlet

Ralph Lauren Outlet

True Religion Outlet

ED Hardy Outlet

North Face Outlet

UGG Outlet

UGG Outlet

North Face Outlet

Ugg Boots Sale

UGGS For Women

Skechers Go Walk

Adidas Yeezy Boost

Adidas Yeezy

Adidas NMD

Coach Outlet