Thursday, August 22, 2013

Confederation Line stations should be designed "with safety in mind"

During yesterday's Transit Commission's presentation on OC Transpo's safety initiatives (which came on the heels of a good deal of negative press surrounding the utility's response to recent sexual assaults), General Manager John Manconi brought up the importance of considering safety in the initial design of transit stations. As tweeted by David Reevely:

I've talked in the past about designing stations in such a way, including Lincoln Fields Station recently as well as Eagleson Park and Ride a couple years ago. Despite the obviousness of considering safety when designing and building these stations, it seems rarely executed proactively. That's a real shame, for two reasons:

  1. If stations aren't designed with safety in mind, then they tend to be unsafe for riders. (Obviously.)
  2. It's always cheaper and more effective to design with safety in mind than to retrofit stations to make them safer.
With this in mind, it behooves the city to consider safety as the designs of Ottawa's newest transit stations are finalized--especially those within the downtown tunnel. If the most recently-issued concept designs of the Lyon, Parliament, and Rideau stations are accurate, then the city needs to re-assess their design in order to make them safer.

These conceptual images below show a "side platform" configuration for all three underground stations, with eastbound and westbound platforms separated by the tracks themselves (and a big fence/barrier between them). I'm not sure why the choice was made to use side-platforms; they tend to be somewhat less crowded/hectic for riders and offer the potential for more retail space, but I've yet to read justification from the city's side.

Lyon Station:



Parliament Station:



Rideau Station:



They all look pretty similar (a separate problem), and they're all designed with side platforms--which goes against the recommendation that all three stations feature 180-metre long centre platforms, which was made in the December 2009 Planning and Environmental Assessment study. This image, from that study, shows the difference:



As you can see, the centre-platform design features a much more open area for riders. It would definitely be hectic during rush hour, and may even be slightly confusing for infrequent users unless there's ample very clear signage of which trains go where. On the other hand, getting from the westbound to eastbound platforms is an easy couple of steps, as opposed to a couple flights of stairs.

Outside of rush hour, though, the openness of the centre platform is a boon to safety and security. More people are congregating in one area, which is safer (and is the motivation for OC Transpo's current "Night Stop" program). It's also easier for security guards to monitor, and sightlines are greatly improved so people can be vigilant and respond to or report any unusual activity. There are also fewer places for people to hide, lowering the risk of surprise robberies or assaults.

In short, it's a design that makes safety its first priority and doesn't unduly interfere with service in any way that can't be offset with proper signage. If Ottawa is truly going to design its future transit stations with safety in mind, opting for centre platforms would be a good place to start.

15 comments:

Haveacow said...

Only a minor comment, the platform length of 180 metres was dropped to 150 metres when the tunnel alignment was changed to Queen St. from the earlier cross country alignment. The tunnel right of way is also far shallower than the earlier design. Both changes were to save money and stay on budget. At 150 metres the platfroms will be the roughly the same length as a Toronto Subway or Montreal Metro staion. The platform lengths outside of the tunnel were kept at 120 metres and designed to be easily expandable in the future. Both tunnel and non tunnel platforms are abnormally long compared to other North American LRT systems. These lengths will help greatly expand the systems passenger carrying capacity.

Alex said...

The reason for having side platforms is the tunneling style: since one large tunnel is being dug for both tracks the trains will run next to each other as they enter the stations. Putting a platform in the middle may not make the station wider overall, but it does require wider tunnels leading away from the stations so the tracks have room to separate.

Ottawa's tunneling method contrasts with the use of TBMs like Eglinton Crosstown. When TBMs are used for each tunnel separately the space between tracks is already there so centre platforms become the cheapest option. Unfortunately the geology under downtown (rock) doesn't permit TBM use.

Worldlatest carbd said...

Greetings! Very helpful and Useful Information in this particular post! It’s the little changes which will make the most important changes. Thanks a lot for sharing! Ottawa jobs

750unique said...

2015-07-28song
air max 2015
longchamp pliage pas cher
ray ban sunglasses
longchamp outlet online
ralph lauren polo shirts
true religion jeans
soccer outlet
retro jordans
michael kors handbags
kate spade
michael kors purse
kate spade handbags
michael kors handbags
pandora charms sale clearance
michael kors outlet online
louis vuitton sito ufficiale
michael kors bags
air jordan uk
michael kors
cheap snabacks
football jerseys
rolex watches
coach outlet store online
cheap jordans free shipping
tory burch outlet
coach outlet
burberry scarf
prada shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
burberry handbags
mcm bags
tory burch shoes
cheap oakleys
prada outlet store
ray ban outlet

Fangyaya said...

coach outlet
christian louboutin shoes
ray ban sunglasses outlet
ghd flat iron
christian louboutin sale
polo ralph lauren
ray ban outlet
louis vuitton bags
michael kors outlet clearance
canada goose
coach factory outlet online
cincinnati bengals jerseys
lebron james shoes 13
retro 11
louis vuitton outlet
celine outlet
cheap air jordans
jordan 3s
replica rolex watches
coach outlet online
coach outlet
adidas nmd
coach factory outlet online
cheap toms shoes
hermes birkin handbags
oakley sunglasses outlet
air jordan 11
michael kors purses
air jordan 8
abercrombie and fitch outlet
nike tn pas cher
ugg boots
cheap jordan shoes
fitflop shoes
moncler coats
michael kors outlet
jordan 6s
nike air max uk
cheap uggs
ray ban outlet
20168.11chenjinyan

raybanoutlet001 said...

cheap jordan shoes
nike roshe run
http://www.nikedunks.us.org
adidas stan smith
michael kors handbags,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors clearance
lacoste outlet
nike zoom

Pengobatan Jantung Bocor Secara Herbal said...

Nice, have the motivation for everything

Pengobatan Ampuh Jantung Lemah
Obat Jantung Bocor
Obat Pelancar Bab
Cara Cepat Menyembuhkan Kanker Tenggorokan
Pengobatan Jantung Bengkak
Inilah Khasiat Kulit Manggis Untuk Kanker Payudara

Unknown said...

true religion jeans
michael kors outlet online
mulberry handbags
cartier watches
ray ban sunglasses
instyler ionic styler
montblanc pens
oakley sunglasses
polo ralph lauren
louis vuitton handbags
chanyuan10.22

chenmeinv0 said...

louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
sac louis vuitton
mbt shoes clearance
mbt outlet
heat jerseys
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet online
michael kors handbags
201611.17chenjinyan

John said...

moncler uk
polo ralph lauren
coach factory outlet online
jordan shoes
hollister clothing store
michael kors outlet canada
ray ban sunglasses discount
polo ralph lauren outlet
air max 90
coach factory outlet online
20161206yuanyuan

chenmeinv0 said...

nike roshe flyknit
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton
roshe run 3
converse shoes
adidas outlet store
columbia shoes outlet
louboutin
air max 95
ralph lauren polo shirts
20172.25chenjinyan

Pengobatan Hernia Untuk Semua Usia said...

Soon overcome all the problems your illness complaint before everything gets worse

Obat Asma Tradisional
Cara Herbal Mengobati Laringitis
Cara Ampuh Menyembuhkan Alergi Menahun
Pengobatan Yang Ampuh Batuk Kering
Pengobatan Batuk Berdahak Herbal
Pengobatan Kudis Secara Merata

caiyan said...

pandora charms
cheap jordan shoes
michael kors outlet
coach outlet online
moncler jackets
kate spade outlet online
jerseys cheap
tods shoes
chi flat iron
eltics jerseys
20170320shizhong

chenmeinv0 said...

christian louboutin pumps
longchamp bags
adidas originals tubular
ralph lauren outlet
clarks shoes outlet
coach outlet canada
clarks shoes outlet
michael kors handbags
pandora charms
columbia sportswear outlet
2017.4.24xukaimin

chenlina said...

canada goose outlet
giuseppe zanotti outlet
fitflops sale
ray ban sunglasses outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
asics shoes
ray ban pas cher
fred perry polo shirts
oakley sunglasses wholesale
polo ralph lauren outlet online
20170528wanglili