Wednesday, September 30, 2015

Expensive new Park & Ride planned for Kanata

Yesterday, the Ottawa Citizen published a new Kelly Egan column on the planned Park & Ride in Kanata at the intersection of Innovation and Terry Fox drives. As Egan explains, it's a pretty expensive project:
"It’s to open in the fall of 2016 and Phase 1 will have room for 300 or so cars. It will cost $8.3 million. This excludes the $5.7 million for the land. Yes, that makes $14 million, or $47,000 per spot, given away free to the user."
The Innovation Park & Ride is expected to open in the late fall of 2016.

Park & Rides are a double-edged sword. They make it easy for suburban commuters (and especially rural or out-of-town residents) who have a car to leave it in the suburbs--thus avoiding downtown parking fees--while still getting to work in a reasonable amount of time, thanks to Ottawa's well-developed Transitway system. This makes the service easier and more convenient for a certain group of riders.

On the other hand, as Egan discusses, they can be very expensive capital projects.

From a system standpoint, though, Park & Ride lots can also undercut OC Transpo's efforts to build a system that offers service within reasonable walking distance of most houses. Express buses are a significantly costly service to offer; it takes a lot of time to deadhead the bus to its starting point, and then have meander through suburban streets, before hitting a Park & Ride, filling up, and heading onto the main Transitway arteries. That time means money, going to the operator's salary as well as fuel and maintenance. Many express buses aren't full by the time they arrive at a Park & Ride lot, but they're usually full when they leave because they offer riders the option to bypass the express route's "local" segment and just hop on for the speedier portion.

This option, it turns out, is very popular, and Ottawa's Park & Ride lots are, in many ways, victims of their own success. The Eagleson Park & Ride, for instance, is regularly above capacity--which is why the Innovation Park & Ride is being planned, and why it's plan includes an optional second phase that would include another 500 spaces on top of the 300 included in Phase 1.

Looking at the issue critically, it seems odd that Ottawa invests such a large amount of money building these lots to make transit service more convenient for those who can drive to it, yet they have given little consideration--aside from a small number of permits sold--to recovering much of that investment. It may be time to examine parking fees for everyone who elects to use the Park & Ride service.

The fee need not be large; a nominal fee of $2 per day would help control the currently off-the-charts popularity of Park & Ride Lots, while also offering some much-needed additional revenues for OC Transpo and without making the service less accessible--those who can't or would rather not pay the parking fee can simply connect with a local bus, or catch an express route nearer their home.

Parking fees for Park & Ride lots would also allow Ottawa to recover money from those who may not otherwise be paying for these services, including commuters and users from communities outside city limits.

Growth of Ottawa's Park & Ride lots is a good sign of the convenience they offer, but it's also an unsustainable. New options need to be considered, and one of those may be charging Park & Ride users.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

I thought the purpose of Park & Ride is to allow people who would normally drive to work to use public transit easier, not to allow the city hall/whatever level of goverment to make a profit.
I also thought the purpose of government is to offer services to the people, since those services are paid for by taxes. Not to recover costs, not to make profit, not to be a business. But I may be old-fashined ...
So I see no real problem with this new Park & Ride working as intended and allowing people __who take public transit__ to park there for free.

Anonymous said...

It should absolutely be free. For $3, you need to getting something other than simply a ride downtown.
At this point, if you have 2 people to transport, it is more practical and almost the same price to take Uber, OC transpo needs to start making their service look more attractive, for so many reasons that I won't even attempt to get into now.

Fangyaya said...

ugg sale
air jordan femme
ray ban sonnenbrille
uggs for cheap
adidas shoes
coach factory outlet
air jordan 4
fitflops sale
fitflops sale
jordan 3 retro
ralph lauren outlet
concords 11
true religion jeans
christian louboutin shoes
rolex watches
true religion jeans
ralph lauren outlet
kobe 8
canada goose sale
vans sneakers
oakley vault
nfl jerseys
oakley sunglasses wholesale
ralph lauren
adidas trainers
ed hardy outlet
coach outlet online
coach factory outlet online
michael kors outlet clearance
coach outlet
air jordan shoes
nike trainers uk
canada goose uk
lebron 13 shoes
michael kors handbags
toms wedges
michael kors outlet clearance
nike outlet
canada goose outlet
adidas originals store
20168.11chenjinyan

Kristofer Kihn said...

Java Project Help
I need to offer a go-ahead for such an educational post....its truly astonishing

Ken Smith said...

Your all post is really informative. This post is very different post and useful for everyone.
Psychology Capstone Project Writing Service

Lewis Owen said...

Electrical Project Help
I want to say about this article, uummm this is amazing and nice post.

David Richard said...

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial.
essay writting service

Dr.Brian John said...

Your articles make whole sense of every topic.over 60s dating

James Bond Bond said...

Enormous blog you individuals have made there, I entirely appreciate the work.free sports picks

Pocha huntas said...

Fine method of telling, and enjoyable article to acquire factual statements.web design and search engine optimization agency in Atlanta

Jesica Alba said...

I went over this website and I conceive you've got a large number of splendid information,hardwood floor refinishing nyc

Feonacy Tyson said...

If you want to solve your issue anytime and as well as in the most competitive prices I would definitely recommend them for this business!! They are the best!best tankless hot water heater

Anne Lin said...

Our Buccaneers House Flag hangs vertically and provides a top sleeve for insertion of your flagpole. The Buccaneers House Flag measures 28x42 inches, is constructed of 2-ply polyester, and both sides are dye sublimated with the NFL team logo as shown.The house flag for Buccaneers has a liner sewn between its two polyester sides, therefore, this flag is viewable and readable correctly on both sides.Hang your Buccaneers House Flag with our banner pole or fly it with our 5' wood flagpole and adjustable flag bracket.nfl american flags,
stars and stripes flags,Cincinnati Bengals house flags
Packers stars and stripes flags
nfl house divided flags,
nfl house flags,
college flags 3x5,
Sports flags and banners,

lionel abi said...

I still liked this article, good, good content, and unique design.Thank you for sharing the article.
cara mengatasi kelebihan asam lambung, terbukti ampuh mengatasi lambung perih

chenmeinv0 said...

north face jackets
jordan shoes
birkenstock outlet
fitflops sale
adidas stan smith shoes
polo ralph lauren outlet
adidas 11pro
canada goose outlet
under armour shoes
air jordans
2017.4.24xukaimin

obat perangsang wanita said...

Hey i follow your blog, i like n read every you post

obat perangsang wanita said...

It is a long established fact that a reader will be distracted by the readable content of a page when looking at its layout.