Friday, November 21, 2014

Burying transit, and the people who use it



In its shotgun announcement yesterday, the National Capital Commission laid down the law on Ottawa’s light-rail extension plans from Dominion to Bayview stations: A deep tunnel within the current alignment, or a path across Rochester Field leading Richmond Road—where it would, presumably, also head into a deep tunnel. The obvious commonality here is the complete burial of the light-rail line.

These options, which the NCC “invited” the city to consider, brought to mind an interesting point made to me during the 2013 Car-Free Day street party. A woman there discussed the city’s preferred alignment with me, and expressed her dismay that the beautiful scenery of the Sir John A. MacDonald Parkway was being taken away from transit users. Her point was that the users of transit, many of whom are lower-income residents of our city, were being buried underground in order to preserve the “experience” of private automobile drivers who use the Parkway.

The woman pointed out the fact that as buses today drive along the Parkway, riders are often visibly relieved by the vistas of trees, greenery, and the Ottawa River. Many look up from their phones, books, or magazines and out towards the Gatineau Hills, breathing more deeply and seemingly releasing tension from their daily activities. As a user of the line, this is an experience I can testify to; I often prefer to take an inside seat on the right side of the buses, where I can get a better view out the window.

The city’s preferred plan involves a partially buried line along the Parkway, and it takes our transit vehicles—and the people within then—and pushes them underground. The NCC’s two options would take it one step further, forcing them even deeper underground and out of sight.


One of the NCC’s conditions was that the city achieve “minimal visual impact” and maintain the “user experience” of the Parkway corridor. Their recommendations fail to acknowledge that OC Transpo riders are also users of the corridor, and they should be allowed to enjoy it as well. Although it’s easy to forget, there are people inside the OC Transpo vehicles. They are at least as entitled to the Parkway’s scenery as private automobiles that also use it—and perhaps more entitled, since drivers must remain focused on the road while riders are free to take in the sights.

Ottawa’s western light-rail extension needs to take ecological and community considerations into account. But it also needs to consider the desires of the riders of our transit system.

11 comments:

David James said...

A very good post, Peter. I've had much the same thoughts as your correspondent.

I used Calgary's CTrain for a couple of years and the worst parts of it from a passenger perspective were far and away the underground sections, albeit mercifully short. While light rail is generally quiet on the surface, both for passengers and those outside, in a tunnel it's really noisy.

By contrast, the most pleasant parts of the CTrain are when it was above ground and you get a good view of the city from the top of the river escarpment north of the downtown.

I was also impressed with how easily the CTrain could be fitted into residential areas, something that we in Ottawa are unfortunately disinclined to do.

It's for these reasons that I really don't get the opposition and I have to say I'm very dismayed at the attitudes of the people who live just a mile or so west of me.

Fraser Pollock said...

The attitude of the locals is perfectly understandable, they don't really understand what LRT is, not really. They think it will be like a massively loud freight train going by their homes and no matter how much you say otherwise they don't want their little slice of back yard to change and possibly get worse. Even though the LRT line may actually improve the surroundings. Many of those people are older and most people in those neighborhoods are not transit users so, they don't think they will receive any benefits. They don't like change and they don't trust the process, OC Transpo or City Hall. Until recently they thought they could trust the NCC, now with the NCC's suggestion of using Rochester Field and by association most likely part of the Byron Linear Parkway right of way, they feel truly abandoned. Ironically, what the NCC has suggested is the old proposed Transitway R.O.W. from the 70's that, very few of the locals wanted!

750unique said...

2015-07-28song
air max 2015
longchamp pliage pas cher
ray ban sunglasses
longchamp outlet online
ralph lauren polo shirts
true religion jeans
soccer outlet
retro jordans
michael kors handbags
kate spade
michael kors purse
kate spade handbags
michael kors handbags
pandora charms sale clearance
michael kors outlet online
louis vuitton sito ufficiale
michael kors bags
air jordan uk
michael kors
cheap snabacks
football jerseys
rolex watches
coach outlet store online
cheap jordans free shipping
tory burch outlet
coach outlet
burberry scarf
prada shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
burberry handbags
mcm bags
tory burch shoes
cheap oakleys
prada outlet store
ray ban outlet

chenlili said...

ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet stores
timberlands
louis vuitton handbags
uggs boots
retro jordans 13
abercrombie and fitch
coach outlet store online
cheap toms
asics shoes for men
moncler coats
lebron james basketball shoes
insanity workout
giuseppe zanotti outlet
air jordan homme
coach outlet
marc jacobs outlet
retro 11
ralph lauren outlet
cheap jordans
coach factory outlet online
nfl jerseys wholesale
louis vuitton outlet online
prada outlet
hollister clothing store
michael kors outlet
ray ban eyeglasses
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet online
air force 1 trainers
rolex watches
rolex watches
nike roshe run
hollister clothing
kate spade handbags
michael kors handbags

Anonymous said...

anabolic steroids
Deca Durabolin

Fangyaya said...

coach outlet store online
coach factory outlet
longchamp bags
cheap oakleys
louis vuitton outlet
toms wedges
tiffany rings
adidas nmd
cheap ray ban sunglasses
celine bags
polo outlet
fitflop sandals
burberry sale
louboutin shoes
burberry sale
ray bans
the north face outlet
coach outlet
gucci handbags
louis vuitton handbags
giuseppe zanotti sneakers
ugg outlet
kate spade handbags
moncler outlet
basketball shoes
ralph lauren
coach outlet
true religion outlet online
cheap louis vuitton handbags
moncler coat
uggs outlet
coach outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
adidas stan smith
coach factory outlet
cheap rolex watches
michael kors handbags
cheap ray ban sunglasses
ghd hair straighteners
new england patriots jerseys
20168.11chenjinyan

Gege Dai said...

coach outlet online
coach outlet
uggs canada
coach factory outlet
louis vuitton uk
cheap jordans for sale
fitflops shoes
true religion jeans
nfl jerseys wholesale
swarovski crystal
20170120lck

Obat Ampuh Atasi Kencing Manis said...

Thank you for sharing the information, a very interesting article

Pengobatan Tumor Rahang Sampai ke Akar
Cara Mengobati Asam Urat Ampuh
Pengobatan Herbal Batu Ginjal
Pengobatan Asma Ampuh
Pengobatan Atasi Keputihan Yang Bau Dan Gatal
Cara Mengobati Ginjal Bocor

caiyan said...

asf

Sapna rani said...

Thanks for sharing the post. This is a wonderful and amazing article.I am very glad to be here.Thanks for sharing.
Dwarka best escorts services

chenmeinv0 said...

oakley vault
nike roshe run
adidas ultra boost women
christian louboutin sale
ray ban sunglasses sale
ralph lauren polo shirts
true religion uk
ralph lauren outlet
adidas trainers
vans shoes
2017.4.24xukaimin